Barstow House Menu

Barstow House in Nichols, NY offers an authentic Italian dining experience steeped in history and flavor. The menu showcases a well-curated selection of dishes that honor traditional recipes while capturing bold, fresh flavors. Standouts include the delicate scallops and the sumptuous Delmonico steak served with baked potato and green beans, embodying comfort and elegance. The Chicken Francese and Filet Mignon are cooked to perfection, tender and rich. Appetizers like Cherry Pepper Poppers and Mozzarella Balls provide a vibrant start, while pasta options such as Pasta Primavera and Cannelloni highlight the kitchen’s expertise in classic Italian fare. The house-made Barstow Bread and cheesy garlic bread are perfect complements to any meal. This menu reflects a passion for authentic ingredients and thoughtful preparation, creating a memorable dining experience. Each dish feels like a heartfelt home-cooked meal, elevated by skillful craft and attentive service—truly a hidden gem worth savoring.